Goodfellas – Italian Restaurant in Rotherham

Popular times Estimated

An estimate for a typical Saturday, based on usual demand at restaurants of this type. It is not based on live visitor data.

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

Price level: ££ (moderately priced)

Starters

Zuppa del Giorno (V)Chefs own home made soup of the day.£7
Antipasto MistoA platter of mixed italian cured meats, served with grilled and marinated vegetables and italian cheeses.£12.50
Polpette al SugoItalian meatballs of beef mince cooked in a rich tomato sauce and chilli£9.50
Funghi con aglioPan fried mushrooms with olive oil, garlic, white wine, fresh parsley, served with a salad garnish£7.95
Funghi e PancettaOven baked mushrooms with garlic, bacon, tomato sauce, chilli and mozzarella cheese£8.95
Involtini di SalmoneSlices of smoked salmon rolled and filled with prawns and topped with a homemade mariarose sauce.£10.50
Bread and Olives£7
Garlic bread PlainGarlic bread plain£6.50
Garlic bread tomato and basilGarlic bread tomato and basil£7
Garlic bread tomato and cheeseGarlic bread tomato and cheese£7.50
Insalata Caprese (V)Slices of tomatoes and mozzarella cheese, dressed with fresh basil and olive oil.£8.50
Gamberoni piccantiPan fried butterfly king prawns with spicy tomato sauce, garlic, white wine and fresh parsley.£10.50

Pasta

Penne DelicatePenne pasta cooked with prawns, smoked salmon, asparagus, white wine and cream.£15.95
Penne Ortolano (V)Penne pasta with mixed vegetables and tomato sauce.£13.50
Linguine BologneseLinguine pasta served in a rich traditional Bolognese sauce.£14.50
Linguine MarinaraLinguine pasta served with cherry tomatoes, tomato sauce, garlic, white wine, mixed seafood and fresh parsley.£15.95
LasagnaLayers of fresh pasta, rich bolognese and béchamel sauce, mozzarella and parmesan cheese.£16
Penne AmatricianaPenne pasta cooked with onions, tomato sauce and pancetta£14.50
Penne Funghi e Asparagi(V)Penne pasta cooked with mushrooms and asparagus, finished in a dolcelatte cheese sauce and touch of cream.£14.50
Penne boscaiolaPasta served with pancetta, onions, mushrooms, touch of tomato and cream.£16

Pizzas

Margherita (V)Tomato sauce, mozzarella.£12
Salame piccanteTomato sauce, mozzarella, spicy salami, oregano.£13
Vegetariana (V)Tomato sauce, mozzarella, mushrooms, peppers, red onions, olives£13.50
Prosciutto e FunghiTomato sauce, mozzarella, ham, mushrooms.£14
CalzoneTomato, mozzarella, mushrooms, spinach, ham, spicy salami, topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.£15.95
Calzone Vegetariano (V)Tomato, mozzarella, mushrooms, onions, peppers, spinach, topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.£14.50

Meat

Seafood

Sides

Menu items and prices as published by the restaurant, collected on 16/09/2026. Dishes and prices change; please check with the restaurant when you book.

Location and map

Goodfellas, 53 Sheffield Road, Rotherham S60 1DA

Get directions Open in Google Maps

About Goodfellas

Located in Rotherham, Goodfellas is an Italian restaurant. You will find it at 53 Sheffield Road (S60 1DA). It sits in the Rotherham council area, part of Yorkshire and The Humber. UK Rest lists 33 other restaurants in the S60 postcode district.

As the restaurant puts it: “Come and enjoy an authentic Italian experience in our stylish intimate surroundings. All our dishes are prepared with passion using fresh ingredients.” We found 37 dishes on the restaurant's own menu, with prices from £3.50 to £27.50. Prices are moderately priced, rated ££ on our three-point scale.

Customers can use table bookings. The Food Standards Agency register shows a hygiene rating of 5 – very good – dated 27/09/2023. The telephone number is 01709 837373.